Shine from Yahoo ran an article about a 13-year old girl whose parents made her stand for 90 minutes at a roadside with a sign that said, “I’m a Self-entitled teenager w/NO Respect for authority. I’m also super smart, yet I have 3 ‘D”s because I DON’T CARE!”
This might be a kick in the pants to scare her into bringing up her grades. But in the long run, is this the kind of tactic that will bring out the best in her? Do decent people humiliate each other?
Who are the best supervisors and coaches? Back in my previous life as a career woman, I had a great boss. She had high expectations, and I did not want to let her down. I wanted to do well in that job. Why? Because she set a fine example. She had a strong work ethic, was knowledgeable about her field, was a great team-builder, and encouraged me. These are the things that make a great boss. As I develop my parenting skills, I look to her example. I want my kids to feel encouraged to do their best.
This boss never, ever did anything to humiliate me, even when I really screwed up. I don’t do my best when I am scared. I suppose I’d run my fastest if I were chased by a wild animal. Other than that, does fear bring out the best in any of us? Maybe it does for some people of a certain temperament, but I doubt it is common. And even if humiliation was effective, is it the right way for a person to teach another person, whether adult or child? Would this husband and wife treat each other this way?
I do not think that scaring and humiliating our children into submission brings out the best in them.
I admit there have been times when my children have acted disrespectfully toward me. But it was not because I didn’t scare or humiliate them enough. It was because I got flustered, lost my temper, and had mommy-tantrums. I was being weak, and they could see that I was not in control. That is how I lost their respect. As I learn to keep my temper, speak calmly and firmly, and encourage them to do their best, I can see that I gain their respect.
Many people commented with praise for the parents who wrote the embarrassing sign. I think it is a good thing that the parents wanted to correct their daughter’s behavior. But I am amazed that so many people think that this is a great method. I think it was a desperate, thoughtless, maybe even sadistic measure, and not a long-term solution. I think it is sad that the girl’s behavior stemmed from the tragic death of her uncle, and that her parents responded by hurting her. What a slap in the face to say the girl doesn’t care. Obviously she does care, or her uncle’s death wouldn’t have had such a strong effect on her. And why make a public display of a private matter? I hope that these parents will empathize with her grief and help her work through it in a constructive way. I hope that they strengthen their relationship with their daughter and develop true respect.
Because fear is different from respect.